click to view mobile Navigation
You are here > BREAKING NEWS... Supreme Courts hold that the Employment Tribunal fees regime introduced in 2013 is unlawful

BREAKING NEWS... Supreme Courts hold that the Employment Tribunal fees regime introduced in 2013 is unlawful




The government has lost its case in the long running dispute over Employment Tribunal fees after the Supreme Court ruled that these fees are unlawful. The decision is quite simply the most dramatic judicial intervention in government policy in the whole history of employment law.

Tribunal fees were introduced in July 2013. Fees started at around £160 and increase to between £230 and £950 for further hearings. For certain claims, Claimants may have to pay up to £1,200.

Since the fees were introduced, there has been in excess of 70% reduction in cases.

Unison’s challenge is possible because Parliament never passed an Act requiring Employment Tribunals to charge a fee. This major change in the way in which employment law works was introduced through secondary legislation. When a Minister introduces secondary legislation, they must act in accordance with the legal principles laid down by the courts. Unison argued that Employment Tribunal fees restrict access to justice and that a Minister can only introduce an order which does that if the restriction goes no further than is proportionate, given the legitimate aims lying behind the decision.

The issue that really caught the attention of the Court was the sheer unreasonableness of paying a hefty Employment Tribunal fee to pursue a very small claim. The Tribunal system was designed for small claims. Unlawful deductions from wages, for example, may concern very small sums of money that are nevertheless vital to those who have not been paid what is owed them by their employer. But to take a Tribunal case to a full hearing on that issue, the Claimant has to fork out £390.

The Government argued that if a Claimant cannot afford to pay that fee, there is a remission system which may allow the fee to be waived. But Unison’s point, which the Supreme Court was sympathetic to, was that even if you could afford to pay the fee, why would you? It is foolish to spend £390 in the hope of recovering £100 in unpaid wages. All litigation carries a risk, and even if you win the case, there is a further risk that the employer will simply not pay. The fee system Unison has succeeded arguing about, has denied thousands of individuals access to justice by effectively rendering the pursuit of their claims pointless.

Another significant point of Unison’s case is discrimination, as women are disproportionately affected by the higher fees.

The Government was given a rough ride by the Supreme Court and were not impressed with the lack of thought that had gone into setting the level of the fees, assessing their impact or in setting the criteria that would determine whether an individual qualified for remission.

The Supreme Court were highly critical of the way in which fees were introduced and the effect that they have had, which led to them deciding that the Government acted unlawfully in introducing them.

This decision is dramatic and essentially says that a major government policy is illegal. The result for Unison has opened a new chapter in the Supreme Court’s willingness to limit the powers of the Government. It asserts the sovereignty of Parliament as expressed in Acts of Parliament against the power of ministers who shape laws through orders and regulations which have slipped through with minimal scrutiny.

This is quite simply the biggest decision in the history of employment law and is a very big deal. Bearing in mind the extent to which the Brexit process is likely to rely on ministers introducing secondary legislation, it could have ramifications well beyond employment law.

If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to get in touch with Sally Morris at sally.morris@mfgsolicitors.com or on 01905 610410.




< Go Back

LATEST NEWS


Hewett’s ‘values’ recognised at staff awards
Hewett’s Annual Family Fun Day and Company Awards took place at the West Midlands Safari Park in July.
31/07/2017 15:50:48
Read More >>

BREAKING NEWS... Supreme Courts hold that the Employment Tribunal fees regime introduced in 2013 is unlawful
In this Legal E-Bulletin we share a useful article published by mfg Solicitors looking at the new ruling surrounding Tribunal fees that has just been released.
26/07/2017 14:33:58
Read More >>

Safari Park Fun for Annual Family Day!
Hewett Recruitment held their annual Family Fun Day and Staff Awards at West Midlands Safari Park on the 16 July. Staff and families came together to enjoy the surroundings of the picturesque Spring Grove House set in the beautiful Bewdley countryside.
17/07/2017 10:29:51
Read More >>

**HOT OFF THE PRESS** REC launches Immigration Report
The Recruitment & Employment Confederation commissioned a comprehensive and insightful analysis into how EU nationals currently participate in our labour market, and how this may change post-Brexit.
29/06/2017 13:42:27
Read More >>

Hewett's Managing Director signs up to 'Worcester Stands Tall'
Since the launch of Worcester Stands Tall we have had an amazing response to the event. Many giraffes sculptures have been sponsored and over the coming weeks we will be announcing our sponsors and what inspired them to get involved.
21/06/2017 14:52:27
Read More >>

LATEST BLOG


Hiring decisions can have a huge impact
In today’s tight labour market, the answer might not always lie in a candidate’s level of experience. Growing businesses are recognising that selecting people on potential, passion and possibility – a ‘high potential hire’ may be the best solution when the experience is somewhat elusive.
19/07/2017 11:38:35
Read More >>

Legal E-Bulletin - Getting back to the fundamentals of employment law
With all the changes in legislation and pressures of UK Law, it's important not to forget some of the more basic and fundamental issues of employment law. Sally Morris, Partner and Head of Employment for mfg Solicitors shares her thoughts.
18/07/2017 16:32:54
Read More >>

Supply Chain Success
In the modern day factory, the notion of nipping to the stockroom to get some parts or materials is long gone. We now live in the world of Industrial Vending Machines, where a key code or fob gives users access to what they need and then automatically orders new stock when required via “the cloud”.
05/07/2017 09:57:45
Read More >>

The Significance of an Ageing Workforce
The ageing of the UK population comes as no surprise, but according to a recent report from Mercer the impact of this significant demographic shift has been masked until now by positive net migration. With immigration likely to fall in the coming years, particularly from the EU, the veil is lifted as we face a shrinking UK workforce.
21/06/2017 08:48:52
Read More >>

HR Professionals Conference - 23rd Nov 2017
If you are a business owner, director or HR professional who needs to understand more about what the brave new world of jobs means for skills and business hiring strategies in the future… save this date!!!
17/05/2017 11:21:50
Read More >>